By Kathy Pillatzki
Assistant Director
Henry County Library System
If you’re looking for a
book review, it’s your lucky day! My plan was to review Shadow
of Night, the second installment in the All Souls Trilogy by
Deborah Harkness, I reviewed the first in the series, A
Discovery of Witches, and was eagerly looking forward to the
sequel. However, while reading it I was reminded strongly of
another title I read recently, so I decided on a package deal
…today only, two reviews for the price of one!
First, Shadow of Night.
Before I go any further, let me say that this book is for those
who have read the first in the series. The author makes no
concession to the reader who skipped A Discovery of Witches.
There are no reviews, no recaps, no reference points whatsoever.
In fact, page one of Shadow of Night reads exactly as if
Harkness turned the page from the end of the previous book and
continued her train of thought. It literally picks up at the
exact moment the last one ended.
Those who read A
Discovery of Witches will be enchanted with developments in this
volume of the story of forbidden love between a witch and a
vampire. Historian and witch Diana and geneticist/vampire
Matthew time travel to 1590 England to find a skilled witch who
can help Diana harness her newfound magic, and to search for an
ancient manuscript that may unlock the secret of her powers.
They are helped, and
sometimes hindered, by what seems like a cast of thousands. If
the book has a weakness, it’s that there are so many characters
it’s hard to remember who’s who from one chapter to the next.
But one of the more fascinating elements of the story is that
quite a few of those characters are real historical figures –
Christopher Marlowe, Sir Walter Raleigh and William Shakespeare
– who come into the story in a variety of creative ways.
If you’re tired of the
whole witch and vampire craze, this story may not be for you.
But the author’s real skill is the seamless way in which she
blends historical fact with fantasy fiction. This trilogy is
what the Twilight series would have been if Stephenie Meyer had
an encyclopedic knowledge of art, literature, history,
mythology, and folklore - and a huge vocabulary. It’s Twilight
for grown-ups.
Speaking of teen
literature, though, reminds me of the second book in this
special deal. If you enjoyed the Twilight series, but are ready
to move on to something more challenging yet not as daunting as
an epic like the All Souls trilogy, I highly recommend Once A
Witch by Carolyn MacCullough.
In a
familiar plot, Tamsin has grown up in a family of powerful
witches as the odd man out: prophesied to be the most powerful
of them all, birthday after birthday passes with no sign of any
magical skills at all. When a stranger asks the teen for help
finding a lost object containing ancient magic, she begins to
discover abilities she never knew she had. This is a fun but
well-crafted urban fantasy. If you enjoy it, you can move on to
the sequel, titled - what else? - Always a Witch.